Detailed Proof of Theorem 4.1 in Sense and Denotation as Algorithm and Value
نویسنده
چکیده
§4. Sense identity and indirect reference. Van Heijenoort [30] quotes an extensive passage from a 1906 letter from Frege to Husserl which begins with the following sentence: “It seems to me that we must have an objective criterion for recognizing a thought as the same thought, since without such a criterion a logical analysis is not possible.” This could be read as asserting the existence of a decision procedure for sense identity, but unfortunately, the letter goes on to suggest that logically equivalent sentences have the same sense, a position which is contrary to the whole spirit of [12]. It is apparently not clear what Frege thought of this question or if he seriously considered it at all. Kreisel and Takeuti [17] raise explicitly the question of synonymity of sentences which may be the same as that of identity of sense. If we identify sense with referential intension, the matter is happily settled by a theorem.
منابع مشابه
A Note on the Descent Property Theorem for the Hybrid Conjugate Gradient Algorithm CCOMB Proposed by Andrei
In [1] (Hybrid Conjugate Gradient Algorithm for Unconstrained Optimization J. Optimization. Theory Appl. 141 (2009) 249 - 264), an efficient hybrid conjugate gradient algorithm, the CCOMB algorithm is proposed for solving unconstrained optimization problems. However, the proof of Theorem 2.1 in [1] is incorrect due to an erroneous inequality which used to indicate the descent property for the s...
متن کاملOn the norm of the derived subgroups of all subgroups of a finite group
In this paper, we give a complete proof of Theorem 4.1(ii) and a new elementary proof of Theorem 4.1(i) in [Li and Shen, On the intersection of the normalizers of the derived subgroups of all subgroups of a finite group, J. Algebra, 323 (2010) 1349--1357]. In addition, we also give a generalization of Baer's Theorem.
متن کاملSense and denotation as algorithm and value
In his classic 1892 paper On sense and denotation [12], Frege first contends that in addition to their denotation (reference, Bedeutung), proper names also have a sense (Sinn) “wherein the mode of presentation [of the denotation] is contained.” Here proper names include common nouns like “the earth” or “Odysseus” and descriptive phrases like “the point of intersection of lines L1 and L2” which ...
متن کاملA new proof for the Banach-Zarecki theorem: A light on integrability and continuity
To demonstrate more visibly the close relation between thecontinuity and integrability, a new proof for the Banach-Zareckitheorem is presented on the basis of the Radon-Nikodym theoremwhich emphasizes on measure-type properties of the Lebesgueintegral. The Banach-Zarecki theorem says that a real-valuedfunction $F$ is absolutely continuous on a finite closed intervalif and only if it is continuo...
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
عنوان ژورنال:
دوره شماره
صفحات -
تاریخ انتشار 2007